The Strangers: Chapter 1 is a 2024 horror thriller film directed by Renny Harlin, with a screenplay by Alan R. Cohen and Alan Freeland, from a story by Bryan Bertino. Serving as the third film in The Strangers film series created by Bertino, it is the first installment of a new trilogy of standalone sequel films, where Chapter 1 will follow a similar premise to the the first film and takes place in the same continuity as the first two installments.
After their car breaks down in an eerie small town, a young couple are forced to spend the night in a remote cabin. Panic ensues as they are terrorized by three masked strangers who strike with no mercy and seemingly no motive.
The cast includes Madelaine Petsch, Froy Gutierrez, Gabriel Basso, Rachel Shenton, Richard Brake, Ella Bruccoleri, Ema Horvath, George Young, and Rebecka Johnston.
The Strangers: Chapter 1 made its debut in theaters on May 17th, courtesy of Lionsgate.
Back in 2008 The Strangers hit theaters and became a cult classic pretty much instantly. The film, which was said to be based on true events, brought to the forefront the idea of random acts of violence which is a problem in our country. The idea of complete strangers terrorizing innocent people for no apparent reason whatsoever is a terrifying proposition, especially when the victims are at their mist vulnerable. I personally loved The Strangers and was 100% on board with building out a franchise, although for one reason or another it took 10 years before the release of the sequel, The Strangers: Prey at Night (our full review here). Considering my love for the original film and the long wait for the sequel, this movie was a big time disappointment for me which was definitely a bummer. I wasn’t sure if we would see this franchise again or not, but here we are with what is designed to be the resurgence for a new trilogy, and it all starts with The Strangers: Chapter 1.
I hate to be the one to say this but when it comes to this movie the bad far outweighs the good, but it still has redeeming qualities. It is essentially the same exact premise as the original film so I knew what to expect, and this had me focusing more on the characters and the overall build-up to the final act. I thought the opening was pretty solid overall as it set the tone with this sketchy and very unwelcoming small town where this couple ends up stranded while on a road trip. The film did a nice job making viewers feel uneasy as they awaited what was sure to be a very long night for this couple. I thought the score/soundtrack was very effective thanks to composer Justin Caine Burnett, who made the most of his biggest project to date. I liked the use of music throughout the film which gave viewers this sort of false sense of security, and I loved how the score went up to a 10 during the more tense scenes. Burnett really helped to make this feel like a The Strangers film and you can’t ask for much more than that.
I also want to give credit to cinematographer José David Montero for ensuring the film had a ton of really great shots of our favorite trio of murderous psychopaths. I really liked the look of the three intruders this time around, and the Jason Voorhees pre-hockey mask vibe I was getting from the male character had me pretty excited. He was much bigger this time around, and I also preferred the masks on the two female characters as well. To be honest I liked everything about the three killers, the way they carried themselves, the fact that they barely spoke which is true to the original, and the vibe that you get making it clear that they want to make these people suffer as they fully intended to drag things out as long as possible. I also really liked that they stuck with the iconic old Ford truck as well.
As I mentioned earlier the premise for The Strangers: Chapter 1 is very simple and basically a direct remake of the original film, or I suppose a remake/prequel depending on where they take things with the next film. With that being said I was surprised by the fact that the most glaring weaknesses for the film were tied to the story and the characters. The film was made on a shoestring budget of $8.5 million which is just barely below the budget of the original film, so I didn’t expect any real star power or really anything like that but to say the ball was dropped when it came to casting and the screenplay would be an understatement. Brian Bertino set the groundwork for the story so all screenwriters Alan R. Cohen and Alan Freeland had to do was not mess with the formula too much which was apparently easier said than done. At times the story was just painful, and the majority of the dialogue was cringeworthy.
I blame poor writing for the most part because at the end of the day the actors are doing what they are told, especially lower-tier actors just trying to make a name for themselves, and it is up to the director to ensure the vision for the film translates to the screen. Unfortunately director Renny Harlin seemed ill-equipped to deliver what fans needed from this film, which to be honest wasn’t really asking a lot. I absolutely hated the lead male character of Ryan, played by Froy Gutierrez, right from the start. I didn’t need a lot from him but to me he was just unlikable, and the fact that he wasn’t supposed to be unlikable just made it worse. A few of his earlier interactions in the film with the local townspeople soured him for me, but it continued on throughout the film as the way he reacted to stressful situations just annoyed me.
It wasn’t the usual overexaggerated reactions you sort of expect from these films or just the “why would you do that?!” moments, but more so these odd and just unnatural reactions. As I said I don’t think the blame should fall solely on Gutierrez as I do believe he put forth his best effort, just the writing and the dialogue was so bad at times that he was fighting a losing battle. Thankfully they kept things simple with the character of Maya played by Madelaine Petsch, and all things considered she looked the part and kept things moving well enough. I mean she didn’t really move the needle for me but she was fine. The marketing team did a heck of a job promoting the film leading up to the release, its just too bad those in charge of the actual film failed to deliver. Plus I would love for someone to explain to me why this movie received the R-rating because I am getting sick of this rating getting attached to films when it feels incredibly unwarranted.
THE VERDICT
A lackluster attempt to reinvigorate the franchise plagued by lazy writing and a lack of creativity, The Strangers: Chapter 1 trips all over itself when it matters most yet still somehow retains a glimmer of hope for the next film in the new trilogy. As I talked about during the review the film has redeemable qualities and does some things well, but unfortunately the good is overshadowed by the bad.
I’m really not asking for a lot with these films, and to be honest I don’t even expect them to be scary. I just want a commitment to the formula, simple as that. Hopefully the next film gets this bad taste out of my mouth especially after The Strangers: Prey at Night, otherwise this franchise will forever be remembered as all bark and no bite.
TED TAKES RATING - 5.2/10
The Strangers: Chapter 1 is now playing only in theaters. Check out the latest trailer below.